My cat is super picky about her wet food, it cannot have clumps, pate must be super thin, and it must not smell too overpowering. I was spending a fortune on broths and canned food and she was still not eating it all and portioning it out was a pain. When i found these I figured it woukd be more thick, but it is super creamy and kind of thin, similar to yogurt. In my opinion they are fairly smelly, but my cat literally cannot wait until i out them in her bowl. She will even eat it from the tube. I usually give her one for dinner. She is absolutely obsessed!